What Japanese Schools are Doing Right

I recently had the opportunity to visit a Japanese school. Kadena Elementary School is located on Okinawa Island in the town of Kadena, and is not to be confused with the school of the same name operated by the U.S. Department of Defense Dependents Schools.

The purpose of my visit was to research successful practices of the Japanese school system that could be used to improve the American school system. As an educational researcher, I believe that cultures should borrow the best practices from each other.

During my visit to Kadena Elementary, I observed several practices that worked well and could be adopted by American schools.

First, Kadena Elementary has a social curriculum in addition to an academic curriculum. For example, the students clean the school every day by themselves; there is no janitor. They sign up for chores on the blackboard. The Japanese custom of removing street shoes at the front door of the school and replacing them with shoes only worn indoors makes cleaning somewhat easier.

Also, the students serve the school lunch to the teachers and themselves; there are no cafeteria workers. After lunch, the students clean up after themselves.

The social curriculum helps students develop responsibility and a strong work ethic. It’s an idea that could work well in American schools.

The second practice I observed that worked well is that the students eat a healthy diet. There are no soda vending machines at Kadena Elementary. The school lunch is planned by a dietician and prepared at a central location in the school district. It’s then delivered daily to every elementary, middle, and high school in the district. Japanese schools do not have cafeterias. Students eat lunch in the classroom with their homeroom teacher.

The school lunch I ate at Kadena Elementary consisted of rice, soup, broiled fish, and milk. By comparison, the American school lunch typically consists of processed foods higher in fat and sugar.

Third, the students stay active at Kadena Elementary. They have recess every day and participate in a rigorous physical exercise program. In contrast, American schools are cutting back or completely eliminating recess and physical education.

Besides recess and physical education, the students also stay active in the classroom. I observed classrooms wherein students were not just passively sitting still listening to the teacher; they stood up and moved around while learning. They played educational games and learned by seeing, hearing, and doing.

Studies show that proper nutrition and increased physical activity lead to higher academic achievement. American schools can improve student learning by serving a healthier school lunch and giving students more opportunities to stay active during the school day.

Japan has outperformed the U.S. in math and science on several international assessments of educational achievement. For example, the average math achievement score for 15-year-old Japanese students was 523 on the most recent Program for International Student Assessment (PISA). American students only scored 474. In science, Japanese students outperformed American students 531 to 489.

The Japanese school system is teaching math and science to students more effectively than the American school system, and it still has enough resources left over to implement a social curriculum, offer healthy food, and allow students to stay physically active during the school day. These are all great practices that American schools should consider borrowing.

2 Comments to What Japanese Schools are Doing Right

  • Eric Pineda

    Hi Bill,

    I absolutely agree on your statement that “cultures should borrow the best practices from each other”. Being a college student in California(which is going through a huge fiscal crisis), I sometimes wonder what types of changes our schools can do in order to eliminate wasteful spending. I could imagine the amount of money a school can save by having its students do the cleaning, however, it would also lead to a lot of job loss. I am still very much FOR the idea of adopting this Japanese system and would like to read more on it.

    Best,
    Eric

  • Kristin

    I have studied the differences between American and Japanese educational systems for quite some years. I have been in education for 14 years now but have not had the opportunity to visit Japan classrooms. There definitely needs to be some kind of system wide change in America as we are falling behind in all academic areas. Our students should be given the tools and opportunities to be successful and for America to continue to be a leader in the world. I would love to read more about your research and some of your ideas for improvement/change. I have even done some research on opening a charter school where these ideas could be implemented but unfortunately to receive state and federal funding the curriculum has to be aligned to the state standards and the students have take the state standardized test. These standards require our students to learn the information in textbooks that are completely vast. Students in Japan have much smaller texts and are required to master subjects before moving on to the next. This is going to be challenging in this country due to the requirement that funding be based on mastery of these standards.

Post a Comment